Showing posts with label faculty development. Show all posts
Showing posts with label faculty development. Show all posts

Introduction: Empowering Online Teaching through Faculty Development

Rogers (1995) defined innovation as, “an idea, practice, or object that is perceived as new by an individual or other unit of adoption.” The articles in this collection have been selected to address the question, how can we promote innovation in teaching? The important distinction for the context of our discussion is that ‘perceived as new’ is relative to the traditional educational practices of a University which consist largely of face to face, lecture style classes. If web-based delivery is adopted and used with the existing instructional paradigms, the effect on learning will be negligible and will therefore not represent an innovation in teaching. Ultimately, it is not the technology that matters, but how we design the learning through the technology (Miller, 1996). Advances in teaching may result when technology is used as an opportunity discover new ways for achieving learning outcomes. Web-based education can represent both a pedagogical innovation and a channel of communication capable of engaging the learner. Technology enables the instructor to create a different kind of curriculum and to establish a different relationship with the student. The virtual classroom provides a new environment for human interaction and allows the teacher to design learning which can be more student-centred and collaborative.


According to Rogers (1995), innovation is adopted by members within society at different times and at different rates. A steep learning curve is overcome quickly by early adopters who absorb the new skills and instructional paradigms quickly while late adopters acquire this knowledge over a longer time span. Information seems to flow easily from innovators to early adopters. The barrier for diffusion is identified by the gap that occurs between early adopters and early main-stream faculty. The size of this gap can be attributed to the level of the interconnectedness between departments at a university. Often faculty have connections that do not extend beyond their department. This limits the reciprocal exchange of teaching methods and content. The number of nodes and connections between departments determines the complexity and richness of the network (Rueter, 1997).

Faculty development is often seen as a key enabler of innovation in teaching as it may serve to link successful teaching initiatives and the broad expertise available throughout a university. Such a network would facilitate the sharing of innovative teaching strategies and encourage the exchange of best practices in the development and delivery of online education. These types of initiatives also help to raise the profile of innovative teaching practices, and foster communication and collaboration between developers and programs.

Each of the following article summaries will examine a different aspect of faculty development and outline the strategies or considerations for promoting innovation in teaching. Together they provide the foundation for the design of the teaching online workshop I deliver at the University of Toronto.

Chapter 1: Online Course Design and Faculty Development

Brown, G., Meyers, C.B., Roy, S. (2003). Formal course design and the student experience. JALN 7(3), 66-77. http://www.aln.org/publications/jaln/v7n3/v7n3_myers.asp


The authors examine the collaboration between faculty and professional course designers at Washington State University and the impact that this work had on the student learning experience. The purpose of this study was to examine whether instructors exposed to the faculty development process were more likely to create technology-mediated learning environments which reflected effective teaching principles. Brown et al. (2003) go on to outline which principles of teaching have the greatest impact on learning. Based on their research they determined that the most important quality of good teaching practice is faculty-student interaction. This type of communication is also the basis for employing other principles of good practice. It is essential in facilitating the exchange of diverse points of view, for providing feedback on performance and for communicating high expectations. Regular interaction also provides the structure necessary so that students’ continue to focus their efforts on required tasks. A series of faculty and student surveys focusing on teaching and learning goals, activities and processes was used to systematically evaluate the use and impact of innovative teaching practices. The research findings suggest that faculty development programs which include pedagogical and technology training enhances the opportunities for interactions which lead to improved student learning outcomes.

This article was chosen because it demonstrates that systematic course design improves students’ opportunities for faculty-student interaction, student-student interaction, and other elements associated with best practice. It provides the rationale for why we employ an instructional design template to help faculty clearly articulate the strategies and technologies for online instruction. Engaging in this exercise gives them an opportunity to identify the types and frequency of communication they would like to occur and how these activities help them to achieve the learning outcomes.

Chapter 2: Constructivist training for Online Teachers

Gold, S. (2001). A constructivist approach to online training for online teachers. JALN, (5)1, 36-57. http://www.aln.org/publications/jaln/v5n1/v5n1_gold.asp


Gold examines the pedagogical role of the teacher in web-based learning, focusing on the training required to make the transition from in-class room education to online instruction. The article focuses on a two-week faculty development workshop aimed at preparing educators to effectively teach online. Participants were engaged in different types of collaborative exercises ranging from virtual field trips, to online evaluations, interactive essays, and group projects. To promote innovation in teaching faculty experienced constructivist approaches first-hand in order to better understand the value of learner-centred instruction. Gold also outlines the case for constructivist online education. As knowledge is based on different experiences and interpretations by the learner, technology can be used to help them make meaning of their environment by providing the tools by which they communicate their understanding of the world. Gold ties Piaget's processes for knowledge construction to the affordances of online learning networks. For example, the online curriculum can be used to solicit problems from students to act as a stimulus for learning activities. The content can be modularized so as to scaffold learning. Collaborative projects can engage students in designing authentic tasks and case studies can be presented to challenge misconceptions of particular theories. Gold tested several research hypotheses to determine the effect of the training on the instructors, most specifically their perceptions of what online teaching involved and concluded that workshop was successful in getting educators to re-examine their current methods of instruction. He also found that, the participants shifted towards a more constructivist orientation, seeing online courses as offering more opportunities for student participation. Of interest is the description and findings of the culminating activity where groups of participants wrote an interactive essay.

I have included this article, because I agree with the author that in order to effectively teach online instructors should experience it from a student perspective, otherwise the tendency is for them to map their existing practice onto the web-based medium. These experiences also help to inform them about the potential benefits and drawbacks of this delivery medium. The design of the course exposed faculty to a variety of instructional strategies and technologies and was the same approach and organizational structure we used in the development of our own web-based workshop at UofT.

Chapter 3: Faculty Development that Works

Morrison, J.L., & Brown, D.G. (2002) Faculty Development That Works: An Interview with David G. Brown. The Technology Source, July/Aug. Available online http://ts.mivu.org/default.asp?show=article&id=997


Morrison and Brown discuss initiatives they have implemented at their institution to promote innovation in teaching. Brown suggests that the necessary pre-conditions for increasing the use of technology in teaching is to provide ubiquitous, reliable access, and providing the time for instructors to learn how to use the different tools for teaching. Faculty will be driven to adopt more effective methods of teaching using technology if they determine that there will be a corresponding enhancement in student learning outcomes. Specific recommendations include a laptop program for faculty and students and an environment which encourages instructors to experiment with technology. Recognizing the enormous time commitment that integrating instructional technology takes is a necessary precondition for a successful faculty development program. The authors also suggest that the focus should be placed on effective teaching practices as opposed to learning how to use the technology in order to encourage faculty to seek opportunities for accomplishing new ways of achieving learning outcomes. The article also addresses issue of rewards for faculty and how to provide incentives for educators to learn about technology. They include, “special stipends, hand-written notes from deans, discretionary spending accounts, priority in the receipt of new technology, the capacity to acquire needed computer peripherals and software, distinguished teaching awards, citation in presidential speeches, travel support to share teaching experiences at professional meetings, and additional salary increases.” Most importantly they share the lessons they have learned in fostering faculty development initiatives. One promising idea that failed to work was purchasing release time for faculty. They found that, “if teaching a three-course load takes 70 hours a week, teaching two courses also demands 70 hours a week. In other words, teaching will always take all the time available.” Their greatest successes in faculty development have come in employing students and professional staff to assist faculty members.

I chose this article because it offers a lot of practical suggestions that can be implemented at an institutional level in order to promote the wide-spread adoption of instructional technology. Some of these initiatives are underway at UofT including; wireless networks, individual web space for faculty and students (UTORweb), a laptop program for Art & Science students and pedagogical and technical workshops for teaching online. The current reward structure is in the form of grants which are provided by the Provost's office (with matching funds from the department) to provide the resources and expertise necessary to develop educational resources that integrate technology.

Chapter 4: Creating Online Lessons

Sleight, D., Reznich, C., Yelon, S., & Williamson, J. (2003) Creating online lessons: A faculty development seminar series. Med Educ Online 8(7), 1-7. http://www.med-ed-online.org/f0000061.htm


The authors describe a seminar series developed and implemented to teach medical faculty to create educationally sound, well-designed online instruction. Medical students in family and community practice are often geographically dispersed for their clinical placements. Online education is a valuable tool for bridging the distance between their placements and their academic center. Participants in the workshop were taught basic instructional design concepts and focused on developing a complete online lesson to develop skills which could later be applied to the design of an entire course. Similar to the UofT workshop, faculty were provided with learning design templates based on the skills and knowledge to be developed. Contrary to the Gold article, this workshop did not attempt to expose faculty to different theories of learning. Rather the content focused on the principles of instruction and the conditions required to elicit certain kinds of performance. What differs from the approach taken at UofT, is that this group of educators also included training in administering the technical aspects of web site and course shell development. This aspect of the course focused on content layout, navigational and compatibility issues using commercial webpage design software. Of particular importance is the changes that were proposed as a result of the course evaluation. Based on the feedback obtained from participants, the authors decided future iterations of the workshop would concentrate on pedagogical issues and that it would be better for support staff to attend to the technical issues of online course development. They also determined that the structure and timeline for the workshop and senior administrative support were important considerations in undertaking such training.

This article serves as a valuable resource as it describes a faculty development program delivered in a medical education context (same participants as the UofT workshop) and provides an alternative method for delivering this type of training. The lessons that were shared by the authors convinced us not to include technical training as part of our online workshop.

Chapter 5: Exemplary Faculty Development Program

Varvel, V., Lindeman. M., & Stovall, I. (2003). The Illinois online network is making the virtual classroom a reality: Study of an Exemplary Faculty Development Program. JALN 7(2), 81-95. http://www.aln.org/publications/jaln/v7n2/v7n2_varvel.asp


The Illinois Online Network (ION) is a faculty development partnership between all forty-eight community colleges in the state of Illinois and the University of Illinois. The network was established to help faculty to develop and deliver web-based courses that reflect best practices and engage students in higher order cognition. The authors outline the programs and resources that ION provides, the effectiveness of the program as a whole, and the lessons ION has learned about providing a large-scale faculty development program. Each partner is represented by a member on the Steering Committee which oversees the direction and scope of the projects implemented by the network. Liaisons at each of the colleges also help to ensure the quality of program delivery. ION uses a multi-faceted approach to achieve its objectives;

• The Making the Virtual Classroom a Reality (MCVR) series of online courses for faculty, aimed at developing an understanding of online pedagogies and technologies
 A Master Online Teacher certificate program
• On-site campus visits, involving a combination of faculty workshops, private consulting, and meetings with faculty, administrators, and technical personnel
• An annual faculty development institute, involving over 170 faculty from ION member institutions
• A Resource-rich website

Source: Varvel et al (2003)

Participants in the MCVR series are assigned a coach who works closely with faculty to develop or enhance an existing course. The practical exercises require faculty to demonstrate the knowledge they have gained by articulating learning goals, role of the instructor, student exercises, assessment and feedback strategies and selecting appropriate technologies to enable those outcomes. Faculty are also given an opportunity to practice facilitating online discussion. The evaluation surveys indicate that ION activities have had a very positive impact on the satisfaction and confidence of faculty teaching online courses with, "91% of respondents strongly agreeing or agreeing that the course gave them skills and techniques directly applicable to their jobs" (Varvel et al., 2003).

This article was selected because is provides an exemplary model for the implementation of a faculty development program for online teaching. What is particularly valuable is the practical approach they have adopted and the level of collaboration which exists between partnering institutions. Participants in the UofT workshop are also engaged in the practical exercise of course development as they learn about the pedagogy of online teaching. We hope to extend our partnerships to other institutions like the University of Waterloo, Ryerson and Georgian College who have all expressed interest in sharing best practices and resources

Conclusion: Faculty Development and Online Teaching

What each of the articles in this collection represent are practical real-world examples of faculty development programs directed at improving online teaching. All of the authors were forthright in sharing their experiences of initiatives that were both successful and unsuccessful. This is a tremendous benefit to those who subsequently undertake similar initiatives, as they can devote their time and energy building on an existing knowledge base as opposed to creating a new one. Each of these studies has at least in some way informed the design of the teaching online workshop at UofT. As with the other studies the purpose of our training is to provide faculty with the experience of an online learner while completing steps towards the development and delivery of their own course. Similar approaches in the design of the courses was also used. Generally, a well-circumscribed body of information was examined within a structured learning environment. The common themes that were explored included; effective practices for teaching and learning, choosing instructional technologies, instructional design methodology, and cooperative learning strategies. Activities were associated with specific material presented to the learner in each unit. For example, upon reviewing material on “How Instructional Technologies Help Learning” the participants are required to complete the corresponding section in their design template.


An additional aspect of the workshops that were cited was the first-hand exposure to a wide variety of educational theories and practices. Participants were actively engaged and given the opportunity to individually reflect on their experiences in order to build upon their prior knowledge of teaching. Collaborative learning exercises provided the social construct for participants to negotiate understanding by exposing them to multiple perspectives and interpretations. This took a variety of forms. Through group discussion, learners worked towards a common understanding of best practices for teaching and then collectively applied the criteria for evaluating web-based courses. In some cases, the instructional design templates developed by faculty were peer reviewed. This kind of exposure lead to Gold's conclusion that, “teachers exposed to the course significantly changed their attitudes towards online instruction, seeing it is as more participatory, and interactive than face-to-face instruction”. The contextual setting for many of the workshops was authentic in that instructors were learning in the same environment they would be required to use for teaching. Experiencing web-based learning from a student perspective helps instructors to become effective online teachers. Being exposed to the strategies and dynamics of online learning seemed to be the best way to inform instructors about the benefits and challenges of this mode of delivery.

A combination of delivery strategies were employed and ranged from blended to fully online sessions. Many began with some type of in-class session and included an orientation to online learning in specific web-based environments. Faculty mentoring and group activities were a common theme throughout making use of asynchronous and synchronous technologies to complete the required learning activities. The main advantage of providing the workshops online seemed to be the degree of flexibility it offered faculty to work around their teaching and research commitments. They were able to access the material from home and a variety of work locations. Although the timelines and the structure of the content were provided by the instructors, the progression through the learning content was self-directed. This was an important delivery strategy as not all of the material was equally relevant to each of the participants. The learners were able to customize the learning by selecting the resources applicable to their specific course. This approach also allowed the instructors to focus their attention on the individual learners and address specific questions or challenges related to the development of each course. To deal with the workload of this approach, team teaching was often implemented to enable a high level of service to faculty. Many of the workshop also served as models for the delivery of web-based education. The instructors used the technological features of the online environments to illustrate the effective online teaching practices articulated in their workshops. For example, email was used to provide individualized feedback, to communicate the expectations and timelines for the learning activities and to synthesize main points of discussion. The asynchronous discussion board reflected the diversity of perspectives and provided an authentic audience for participants to articulate their ideas. The groups section promoted the value of collaboration in the course design process. Multiple examples of online courses and instructional technology were also presented in the web-based materials.

The evaluation of these programs overwhelmingly indicated that faculty development programs aimed at improving online teaching were valued by participants and increased the range of instructional strategies and technologies that they were able to employ.

Instructional Strategies for Teaching Online Workshop

The instructional design template is a practical exercise which outlines the actual steps faculty need to complete in order to prepare their own resources for web delivery. This makes the learning relevant for faculty and therefore they are motivated to complete the activities. The instructor endeavours to provide the learner with frequent feedback and reinforcement adapted to the individual’s level of proficiency and professional context. For example, the feedback the instructor provides for the instructional design template includes specific cases and strategies relevant to the discipline of the faculty member. In addition the learner receives feedback on their template from a colleague who will provide an alternative perspective based on their teaching experiences. Both types of feedback are provided throughout the various stages template so as to reinforce the iterative nature of the design process. See the example of a completed instructional design template and peer review.


The strategy of using Faculty mentoring is an attempt to increase the interconnectedness between faculty in order to bridge the gap between the early adopters of instructional technology and the 'early mainstream'. Interconnectedness is the degree to which units within the organization are linked by interpersonal networks. "A high level of interaction allows ideas to flow more easily between groups and is positively correlated to organizational innovativeness" (Rogers, 1995). Often faculty have connections that do not extend beyond their department. This limits the reciprocal exchange of teaching methods and content. "The number of nodes and connections between departments determines the complexity and richness of the network" (Reuter, 1997).

Faculty mentoring takes two forms; the facilitation of online discussion where participants in the workshop have an opportunity to ask the mentor specific questions about instructional strategies. In 3 days, our mentor had 75 postings in her discussion forum!!! Another method is to provide presentations that take the form of a face to face session which is also be simultaneously webcast to remote participants using the epresence software developed at the Knowledge Media Design Institute. Remote participants have an opportunity to send in their questions to the presenter via synchronous chat and the sessions are archived for later viewing. This serves as an opportunity for faculty to informally share ideas and techniques they use in their online courses as well as a place to learn new strategies for web-based instruction. The other benefit of using the webcast technology, is that we are able to model this approach so that faculty understand the benefits and drawbacks of this approach.

References

Rogers, E. M. (1995). Diffusion of Innovations. New York, NY: The Free Press.

Rueter, J. G., (1999). Faculty Development for Teaching and Learning with Technology: New Directions for PSU, [online]. Available: http://web.pdx.edu/~rueterj/rlw/facdev.

Instructional Technologies for Elearning

"Instructional Technologies for Online Learning’ is the second unit of study for the teaching online workshop and follows the first module on ‘Effective Teaching and Learning’. Unit 2 builds on the foundation laid in the previous module and leads faculty through the process of selecting goals and determining how technology will promote the achievement of these outcomes.


The first activity involves looking at a collection of examples of online learning found on the University of Maryland's Teaching and Learning Resources website. Faculty try to find an instructional strategy or technology they are interested in using in order to determine how they might apply it in their particular context.

Subsequently, faculty begin to apply the procedures for designing instruction. They are required to think about what activities students will be engaged in and what role the instructor will assume (see unit 2 template). These decisions are guided by the examination of best teaching practices which was the focus of unit 1. The selection of the instructional technology will incorporate the knowledge they have gained in the second unit about how these tools engage students in different levels of processing information. In addition, faculty identify factors which may influence the selection of technology (i.e. student access to technology, experiences, locations) as well as any questions they have regarding the instructional technology they have selected. At this stage each learner’s design template is peer reviewed to afford them an opportunity to reflect on the feedback of a colleague and to make revisions before they proceed to subsequent units in which they continue to further develop the plan for their instructional technology.

Effective Teaching and Learning

The first module of the teaching online workshop begins with faculty reflecting on their own personal learning experiences to identify teaching practices that are effective in promoting learning. They consider the following questions;


-Describe a positive teaching/ training session you have experienced.

-What did you learn?

-How did you learn it?

-What teaching practices did the instructor employ to make it a positive learning experience?

-Describe a negative learning experience?

-What had you hoped to learn?

-What teaching practices where not employed and made it a negative learning experience?

Subsequently, they form groups and share their learning experiences. Together, they establish a consensus on a list of 5 best practices for teaching.

Througout the workshop we try to model the Seven Principles of Effective Teaching: as outlined by Graham et. al. (2001) in their adoption of Chickering & Gamson's (1987) criteria for evaluating traditional teaching practices.

This is followed by a presentation from a faculty mentor who shares their insights and experiences with web-based instruction, including some practical strategies for engaging students online.

Sample Faculty Mentor Profile
L is an Assistant Professor in the Division of Biomedical Communications where she has taught a visual problem solving course since 1983. In 1999 she integrated Web Knowledge Forum with f2f learning strategies in this course. Student feedback was extremely positive and resulted in 2 teaching awards and 1 division award. Recently she successfully conducted a comparative study using Web Knowledge Forum and WebCT in a UT interprofessional health sciences education initiative. L has a B.A. in English and Fine Arts, a B.Sc.AAM in Art as Applied to Medicine, a M.Ed. in Higher Education (Health Professional Specialization) and is currently pursuing a doctoral degree in the same field focusing on Knowledge Building/Knowledge Forum.
The purpose of the presentation is to illustrate how the practice of teaching is translated into the online medium. The focus in the first unit, on the practice of teaching and the process of learning reinforces the importance of the pedagogical considerations in adopting educational technology. The activities in this unit are designed so that faculty examine their current teaching practice and identify an appropriate instructional paradigm given their preferred teaching style, learner characteristics and subject matter. Once faculty have clearly articulated a model for teaching, they are in the position to begin analyzing their instruction to discover an opportunity for adopting technology and an appropriate strategy within their course.

References
Chickering, A., & Gamson, Z. (1987). Seven principles of good practice in undergraduate education. AAHE Bulletin, 39, 3-7.

Graham, C., Cagiltay, K., Lim, B., Craner, J., & Duffy, T. M. (2001). Seven principles of effective teaching: A practical lens for evaluating online courses. The Technology Source, March/April. [online ] Available: http://ts.mivu.org/default.asp?show=article&id=839.

Needs Assessment Teaching Online Workshop

Before outlining the themes we examine in the teaching online workshop, I thought I would discuss the initial process of analyzing the needs of our institution and faculty.


By looking at the current practices for teaching online at UofT we were able to define the instructional challenge, and to propose a solution along with a list of tasks that required training. The following 3 challenges were identified. First, some online instructors had limited experience in online learning or teaching. Secondly there was a lack of proper pedagogical training for online learning design and delivery. As a result, these educators tended to map their current practices onto the new medium with little of the transformation that was required to teach online (Gold, 2001). An additional problem was the focus placed on technological applications for online learning.

To provide effective training it was also essential to determine the extent to which instructional technology was being integrated into course delivery throughout the University. Information was collected through a needs assessment survey in order to develop a profile of the learner. This survey revealed the following information;

-target audience
-comprehension level – (establish prerequisites for course)
-learning styles / characteristics
-background experience (pedagogy/ instructional technology)
-familiarity with subject matter
-motivation for taking workshop
The collection of responses to the survey identified the following information;

-what aspect of instructional technology faculty were interested in learning about
-why they needed the training
-what environment (technical / social) they would be applying the learning

This approach was consistent with the Dick and Carey model (1996) which recognized the importance of learner motivation, prior experience and educational context.

The results of the needs assessment reinforced previous research by Gold (2001) which indicated that educators rated the need for training in online teaching as a high priority. Instructional design methodology for re-purposing material for web-based delivery and selecting appropriate instructional strategies which integrated technology were also identified as needs. The designers concluded that instructors would benefit from pedagogical training which addressed the transition required to become an effective teacher in this environment. "Knowing how to teach well in one environment does not presuppose knowing how to be successful in the other" (Gold, 2001). There also appeared to be a trend to offering some aspect of online delivery for courses due to the demand by students who want the benefits offered by this type of strategy.

Our learners are likely to be tenured faculty or instructors with at least 5 years teaching experience. They are currently delivering online courses or in the process of developing resources for web-based teaching. Many of these educators have not taken an online course, or received any formal training in online teaching. It is also likely that they have not completed any formal training in education or instructional design.

These educators are likely to have a positive inclination towards technology and its adoption for enhancing learning. They may view this course as an opportunity to re-think their course design to increase student participation and interaction. The participants will draw upon their previous teaching experiences to decide the appropriate level of online integration.

While there are a wide variety of subjects being taught online at the University, the health sciences (Faculty of Nursing, Health Admin, and Social Work) have recently undertaken initiatives to move their programs to online delivery and may therefore see this kind of training as particularly relevant. The kind of educator who would be interested in taking this course would be motivated by intrinsic factors (desire to learn) as opposed to extrinsic rewards, as there is no formal recognition, for completing this training with respect to promotion/ tenure.

Questions for consideration

What methods do you use to identify your target audience and their needs?

What needs have been identified at your particular institution for creating faculty development programs?

How has your institution chosen to address these needs?

References

Dick, W. & Carey, L.M. (1996). The systematic design of Instruction. New York: Harper Collins.

Gold, S. (2001). A constructivist approach to online training for online teachers. JALN, (5)1, 36-57

Teaching Online Workshop

I am following the advice of Stephen Downes and will be posting the material for my upcoming presentation at the Teaching, Learning and Technology Conference at the University of Ottawa, Feb 26-27, on my weblog. Hopefully, this will provide a basis for an informal discussion about faculty development initiatives related to instructional technology. As Downes has suggested this could potentially "add a dimension not possible to achieve with a strictly in-person event", given the limited time for the presentation. By sharing my notes in advance of the conference, individuals will be able to peruse the material and reflect on some of the ideas I have posed. This format will give us more time and more ways to deal with specific questions people may have about the workshop we have created. I will be interested to see if this approach garners any attention, once I notify the conference organizers and other people from related fields.


My presentation is entitled, "Effective Strategies for Empowering Faculty to Teach Online". Along with my colleague, Rosemary Waterston, I design and deliver a 30 hour online workshop for faculty to develop best practices for learner-centered, web-based instruction. This workshop is accredited as part of the Continuing Medical Education Certification Program offered by the Centre for Faculty Development in Medicine, at the University of Toronto.

My presentation will focus on 3 areas;

Structure for delivering the workshop
Themes explored and resources used to train faculty about teaching online
Strategies designed to promote faculty collaboration in the development and delivery of online learning


Structure for delivering the teaching online workshop
A hybrid delivery format is used for the workshop . It begins with an in-class session and includes an orientation to online learning in the Blackboard courseware environment, a guest lecture presentation by a faculty mentor, and some group activities designed to arouse interest and motivation and to establish the instructional purpose. For the next several weeks, participants are encouraged to login daily to review online lecture notes and resources, participate in asynchronous and synchronous discussions and to complete the required learning activities. The workshop concludes with a face to face session where participants reflect on their web-based learning experiences.

The UofT ‘Teaching Online Workshop’ was created to help educators to teach online by giving them an opportunity to experience web-based learning. The contextual setting for the workshop was authentic in that instructors were learning in the same environment they would be required to use for teaching. We believe that in order to be an effective online teacher, instructors must experience web-based learning from the student perspective (Gold, 2001). Being exposed to the strategies and dynamics of online learning is the best way to inform instructors about the benefits and challenges of this mode of delivery. The knowledge gained from these experiences will help instructors to decide how to best integrate online learning as part of their course delivery. During the workshop the participants are actively engaged in identifying strategies for personal course development and delivery.

The main advantage of providing the workshop online is the degree of flexibility it offers faculty to work around their teaching, research and clinical commitments. They are able to access the material from home and a variety of work locations. Live presentations and synchronous chats are archived for those unable to attend the sessions in ‘real time’. Although the timelines and the structure of the content are provided by the instructors, the progression through the learning content is self-directed. This is an important delivery strategy as not all of the material is equally relevant to each of the participants. The learners will be able to customize the learning by selecting the resources applicable to their specific course. This approach also allows the instructors to focus their attention on the individual learners and address specific questions or challenges related to the development of each course.

Questions for consideration?

What factors influence the decisions about the format for delivering faculty development workshops?

What are some of the significant instructional challenges associated with creating and delivering faculty development workshops?

How have you used technology to overcome some of these challenges?

Future postings will continue to explore the material for my upcoming presentation.

References
Gold, S. (2001). A constructivist approach to online training for online teachers. JALN, (5)1, 36-57

Innovation in Teaching and the Adoption of Instructional Technology

Over the past little while I have been trying to catch up on the work and correspondence that has piled up while I was attending the Teaching, Learning and Technology Conference at the University of Ottawa. I was impressed with the major themes of the conference which included; Can we identify key elements in the process of creation and innovation in teaching and learning?  What are the levers, barriers, challenges, assets, and key success factors to innovation?  Is technology a key enabler of innovation?  Is faculty development a key enabler of innovation? The people at Ottawa's Centre for University Teaching are committed to advancing initiatives which promote scholarship in teaching. I believe that these endeavours are necessary in truly brining a more balanced focus to research and teaching responsibilities in our universities. As it currently stands most universities place a strong emphasis on the research pedigree of faculty for the purposes of promotion and tenure and to a much lesser degree on teaching. I recognize the value that research brings to an institution (i.e. funding, enhanced reputation). However, if we are ever truly going to realize the main stream adoption of innovative instruction in a university setting, then faculty have to be formally recognized for their efforts. As a faculty member, naturally you would ask yourself aside from the intrinsic motivation of wanting to engage learners why would I invest all the time and energy into developing creative methods for teaching, when ultimately what is going to lead to promotion is research?

Many of the people that attended and organized the conference are working hard to change this and I fully applaud them in their efforts. Some examples of initiatives they are currently involved in; Facultydevelopment.ca is a project started by a group of 3M teaching scholars that have built a website to share exemplary practices for instruction with other faculty members throughout Canada. “By providing flexible access to interactive learning materials and a collaborative virtual environment, it addresses barriers that faculty face in their pursuit of lifelong learning - access and time.” Society for Teaching and Learning in Higher Education (STLHE), “is a national association of academics interested in the improvement of teaching and learning in higher education.”International Consortium for Educational Development (ICED), “was established to promote educational or academic development in higher education world-wide.”One of the keynote speakers, Dr. Gary Poole, director of the Centre for Teaching and Academic Growth at UBC and a driving force behind the initiatives I mentioned above, chose to address the topic of Motivation for Innovation in Teaching: Where are the Well Springs? Specifically he examined the conditions which facilitate the adoption of innovative practices, citing examples of how students have often generated or been the source of creative approaches. He went on to suggest that sometimes it is beneficial to learn about a new technology first and then figure out how to incorporate that into instruction. Dr. Poole conceded that sometimes this leads to failure, but that much can be learned from the experience. While I agree that failure produces valuable lessons, this approach to the mainstream adoption of instructional technology has led to some significant challenges at the University of Toronto. If one honestly assesses the current state of online teaching at many universities including UofT, the analysis would lead you to conclude that there is a great deal of web-based education and instructional technology being utilized, but that this has failed to yield widespread creative approaches to teaching. There are indeed instructors who find new and meaningful ways to employ technology to facilitate enhanced levels of learning. However, the large majority of instructors tend to map their traditional practices onto the new medium without a corresponding examination of how technology could change existing instructional approaches. The adoption of technology does not necessarily lead to innovation. In fact, this approach to adopting technology actually creates a barrier to innovation in teaching. In the majority of my instructional design consultations with faculty I spend far more time explaining to them how a tool works rather than looking at how technology can be used to improve instruction. They become fixated on administrative features of courseware tools, and developing skills they will need to relearn when new versions of the software are released. This is not a criticism of faculty. It reflects a reality of not having the proper administrative supports in place. Instead of faculty being freed up to develop teaching skills, their time is consumed by learning the bells and whistles.

True innovation in teaching does not result from adopting technology, rather it comes from re-examining current practice to discover opportunities for how instruction can be changed in order to address the needs of the learner. During this process faculty can be supported in trying to determine how technology can be used to enable new outcomes. For example, in the Teaching Online Workshop we deliver, faculty begin by identifying an instructional challenge they are currently faced with in their class. They combine previously learned cognitive strategies and principles of teaching, along with newly acquired procedures for designing instruction to plan an instructional activity that uses technology to address this challenge. In my opinion, it is this type of framework that is likely to produce truly innovative approaches to teaching. Our reason for developing the pharmacology learning object was because we felt that the text book did not adequately represent or visualize the relationships which exist between therapeutic principles and the parameters relating to the physical and pharmacological properties of drugs. The Flash learning object allows the students to manipulate the variables, and to see the corresponding results in a blood concentration time curve. This enables the students to develop a better understanding of these concepts as they are able to formulate and test hypothesis related to drug administration. Admittedly, I have yet to delve into the book by Poole and Bates (2003) "Effective Teaching with Technology in Higher Education", on current research and best practices on how to integrate technology into teaching in higher education. I will undoubtedly have more to say about this topic once I am done reviewing their book.