Showing posts with label learning theory. Show all posts
Showing posts with label learning theory. Show all posts

Instructional Strategies for Learning Object



Over the next few days, I will demonstrate the application of the learning theories that were used to design the instructional strategies for the pharmacology learning object. As Bannan-Ritland et. al (2000) state, "learning object systems present yet another technology-based instructional delivery environment with exciting features and attributes that can empower learner-driven experiences and promote cognitive processing if pedagogical considerations are taken into account in their development and evolution" (pg 1).

The following learning objectives were identified for the pharmacology learning object.

i. The learner will be able to list and describe the major therapeutic principles of drug administration.

ii. Given a demonstration of a therapeutic principle the learner will be able to identify and replicate the relationship between the concepts (i.e. absorption, distribution, metabolism, and excretion of drugs) that underlie the principle.

iii. The learner will be able to identify the relevant principles which describe the magnitude and direction of change plotted in the blood concentration time curve as well as a visual representation of the area under the curve (AUC).

iv. By manipulating the patient variables, routes of administration and drug dosage the learner will be able to correctly explain, predict and control the effect of these changes on the patient.

Explicitly stating the learning objectives made it easier for the instructional designer to determine the type of learning outcome the goal represented and to prescribe the necessary strategy. The first three learning objectives above corresponded to an expository approach in which the “Basic Principles” tab was designed to demonstrate each principle graphically.

Expository Approach: In this approach the principles were presented and demonstrated, and then learners had an opportunity to practice applying them.

Demonstration Phase (the steps below correspond to figure 2 of the Basic Principles Tab). If you mouse over the image presented in figure 2 you should be presented with a small icon (in the bottom right corner) that will allow you to expand the image to its original size.

1. In the “Basic Principles” tab each principle is stated and then presented visually. At this point it is useful for learners to practice stating the principle. They may want to re-write the principle or attempt to put it into their own words.

2. The demonstrations illustrate how these rules can be used to explain, control and predict the effects of drug administration. The results are plotted in the “Blood Concentration Time Curve”.

3. The description that accompanies the animation explains the ‘whys’ of the principle.

4. The demonstrations refer to concepts (absorption, distribution, metabolism, and excretion of drugs) and terminology (physiology/ anatomy) that the learner may have previously acquired. During this phase, learners retrieve this prior knowledge in order to understand the principles.

Next's weeks post will explain the steps for the practice phase.

REFERENCES

Bannan-Ritland, B., Dabbagh, N., Murphy, K. (2000). Learning Object Systems as Constructivist Learning Environments: Related Assumptions, Theories and Applications. In D. A. Wiley (Ed.), The instructional use of learning objects. Available online http://reusability.org/read/chapters/bannan-ritland.doc

Learning Theory Analysis

Below is an examination of the theories of learning and cognition that influenced the design of the learning object.


Smith and Ragan (1999) stated that it is imperative for authors writing about instructional design to acknowledge the beliefs and values represented in their educational philosophy and that they be based upon theories that have been substantiated by empirical research.

For the development of the pharmacology learning object a pragmatic approach was taken and a combination of learning theories were used, including elements of; behaviourism, generative and cognitive theories and constructivism. Smith and Ragan (1999) defined pragmatists in the following manner. "Pragmatists are inclined to believe that although knowledge is acquired through experience [objectivist], it is personally interpreted through reason and is tentative in nature. Knowledge in a particular field is negotiated based upon an agreement of experts as to a common interpretation of experience or "truth for now". Knowledge built by testing truth for now hypothesis and revising truth as common experience and interpretation implies it should be modified [constructivist]."

I agree with a number of other writers (Ally, 2003; Hannafin, et al., 1997; Wilson, 1997; Duffy & Cunningham, 1996) that there is limited value in asserting which theory of learning is better. Rather, the adoption of a combination of instructional approaches was based on the belief that different instructional conditions are necessary to effectively promote a given type of learned performance. The role of the instructional designer is to prescribe an appropriate strategy and context for learning based on the learning objectives.

Pharmacokinetics is a very complex subject and as a result is one of the most poorly taught areas of the medical curriculum. A radical constructivist would have suggested that articulating goals for learning this subject was inappropriate because educators do not know what learners' need or want to learn (Smith & Ragan, 1999). However, one can't assume that individuals who are novices in this area would have been able to devise an approach to acquire the necessary knowledge and skills. Therefore, learning objectives were developed.

The design of the learning object adopted the following behaviourist attributes. Learning goals were explicitly stated in observable terms in order for the learners to establish whether or not they had achieved the desired outcomes. The learning object was sequenced so that students could progress from knowledge acquisition (using basic principles tab to view demonstrations of the principles) to higher order domains (application of principles using the drug options tab). Feedback was presented to students in the form of a graph which plotted the blood concentration time curve and served as feedback to indicate if the student had applied the theory correctly.

Characteristics of generative learning theory were also evident in the design of the learning object. The learner was actively engaged and assumed primary responsibility for processing the information. The pharmacology learning object required the students to interact with the resource to create an outcome (graph on blood concentration time curve). As a result they were more likely to recall the information than if they had merely read it (Houston, 1991). During the process of gathering data using the inquiry approach the learner was required to isolate relevant variables and form a hypothesis about the example. Students reflected on whether or not the instructional content being presented was consistent with previous experiences or prior knowledge (basic physiology and anatomy, pharmacological concepts). 80% of the students that responded to the learning impact study agreed that the learning object encouraged them to reflect on the material.

In order for learners to register information in their sensory systems, strategies consistent with cognitivist and constructivist approaches were applied. Learners were able to control the pace of the information and were directed to attend to specific information. Color was used to highlight the explanations of principles. The plotting of results in the blood time concentration curve was animated. As the curve was being drawn, a green arrow focused the learners attention on the direction and magnitude of change in the graph. A three step memory model was suggested in order for the learners to transfer the information from short-term to long-term memory.

To promote deep processing of the pharmacology principles the information was presented using the spreading activation model in which the students were able to see the relationship between the variables involved in drug administration and the effect this had on the patient. This approach was in direct contrast to the textbook where the principles are treated as individual concepts. Processing the network of related information provided the students with multiple pathways for assimilating or accommodating prior knowledge with new information and therefore makes it personally more meaningful. The opportunity to interpret their knowledge helped them to understand the context in which the different parameters operated.

REFERENCES

Ally, M. (2004). Foundations of Educational Theory for Online Learning. In Elloumi, F. & Anderson. T. (Eds). Online Learning Handbook. Athabasca University

Duffy, T. M., and Cunnigham, D.J. (1996). Constructivism: Implications for the design and delivery of instruction. In D. H. Jonassen (Ed.), Handbook of Educational Communications and Technology (pp. 170-198). New York: Simon & Schuster Macmillan.

Hannafin, M. J., Hannafin, K., Land, S.M. & Oliver, K. (1997). Grounded practice and the design of constructivist learning environments. Educational Technology Research and Development, 45(3), 101-117.

Houston, J.P. (1991). Fundamentals of learning and memory. 4th ed. Florida: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich.

Wilson, B. G. (1997). Reflections on constructivism and instructional design. In C. R. R. Dills, A.J. (Ed.), Instructional Development Paradigms. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Educational Technology Publications.

Learning Object Design Theory

The design of this learning object is based on Abdelhamid’s (1999) multi-dimensional learning model (MDLM) which depends heavily on illustrations and graphics. It integrates different memory strategies that require the student to think to generate information. His research into the process of learning and memory specify three main principles which enhance the understanding and recall of data.


1) The generation effect. A learner that generates an item is more likely to recall the information than when it is merely read (Houston, 1991). The pharmacology learning object requires the students to interact with the resource to create an outcome.

2) Spreading activation model. Stored information (represented by circles) is more easily retrieved when it is remembered in the context of data which is related and interconnected. Processing of one piece of information leads to the activation of the other related items.

The design of the learning object allows the students to see the relationship between the variables involved in drug administration and the effect this has on the patient.
3) Use of graphics can aid learning better than a verbal description. The animated demonstrations of the therapeutic principles enhances visualization of the affected systems.
source: (Abdelhamid, 1999)

In 1996, the School of Medicine at the University of Auckland conducted a study on the effectiveness of the multi-dimensional learning model. The results indicated that students’ academic performance was significantly increased in the areas covered by the model, while there was no significant improvement in the areas not covered by the model (Abdelhamid, 1997). In addition, the learners stated that they preferred this model for their medical education.

References

Abdelhamid, T. (1999). The multidimensional learning model: A novel cognitive psychology-based model for computer assisted instruction in order to improve learning in medical students. Med Educ Online, 1(1), 1-8.

Abdelhamid, T. (1997). An application of cognitive psychology in medical education using a specific educational program. Tarek's integrated system for learning and memory (TISLM): An evaluation of its effectiveness in improving learning and memory. Master of Literature-education University of Auckland.
Houston, J.P. (1991). Fundamentals of learning and memory. 4th ed. Florida: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich.